
Auto Body Repair
Auto Body Repair for Dents, Scrapes, Rust, and the Panels Insurance Never Sees
Not every body job starts with a crash or a claim. A door creased in a parking lot, a bumper scraped on a garage post, rust bubbling at a wheel arch, a rocker panel going soft, a hood that never matched after someone else's repair. Macarthur's body shop at 170 East Lincoln Avenue in Valley Stream fixes these for a written price, with the same technicians, the same paint shop, and the same manufacturer procedures the collision work gets. Call 516-362-5350 or stop in during shop hours.
Certifications and reviews
The Certifications Behind Every Panel, and What Drivers Say About Macarthur on Google
A body repair paid out of your own pocket deserves the same shop that insurers and manufacturers audit. Macarthur holds certifications from Honda and Acura, Nissan, Infiniti, Hyundai, Kia, Mazda, and Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, and Ram, I-CAR Gold Class training recognition, and OEC certified provider status. Every plaque is photographed on this site.
I got locked out my car on a cold snowy night and Alex came and unlock my car. He was very quick and professional. I would definitely use this towing company again.
Great timing and professionalism. The tow truck driver Carlos was experienced and helpful. I would recommend this company and Carlos to anyone.
Not the usual experience with a towing company. Everyone that I spoke to was polite and respectful and they towed my car with care. Hopefully I never need my car towed again, but if I do, this is who I will be using!
- 16Certifications on the shop wall
- I-CARGold Class training recognition
- 1,800+Google reviews, 5.0 average as of Oct 2026
- LicensedDMV # 7110205 · DCA # 1389419
- 1 ShopTow fleet and body shop, Valley Stream
- 24/7Our own trucks bring the car in
The Google reviews below come from the towing side of the business, where most drivers meet Macarthur first. The body shop is where many of those cars go next, often for a small job that was bothering the owner for a year. If the shop has fixed a dent or a scrape on your car, a few words on Google help the next driver deciding whether a small job is worth doing right.
Small job, same certified shop. Ask to see the plaques when you drop it off.
- Auto Body Repair
- Body Shop
- Auto Body
- Body Work
- Dent Repair
- Scratch Repair
- Rust Repair
- Panel Repair
- Panel Replacement
- Car Body Shop
- Auto Body Shop
- Collision Repair
What Auto Body Repair Covers When It Is Not a Collision Claim: Dents, Creases, Scrapes, Rust, and Worn Panels
Auto body repair at Macarthur is the non-claim side of the shop: dents and creases in doors, fenders, and quarters, scrapes and gouges from posts and curbs, rust at wheel arches, rockers, and door bottoms, panels worn or damaged by age and weather, and repairs from a previous shop that never looked right. The work is quoted for a written price and done to the same standard as the collision work.
The collision side of the shop is organized around insurers, estimates, and supplements. The auto body side is organized around you, a written price, and a car that looks the way it should again. Here is what comes through the door.
Dents and creases. A door ding from the next car over, a crease from a shopping cart, a dent in a quarter panel from a bicycle or a basketball. Shallow and soft dents are pulled and finished; sharp creases and dents on a body line are worked harder or the panel is replaced. The dent repair page goes into which is which.
Scrapes and gouges. A bumper corner on a garage post, a door along a pole, a fender along a wall. Paint and primer gone, sometimes plastic or metal gouged. Repaired, filled where appropriate, and refinished with a blend. The bumper repair page covers the plastic cover specifically.
Rust. Wheel arches, rocker panels, door and tailgate bottoms, the seams around the trunk. Rust is cut out and replaced with new metal, not sanded and painted over. The rust section below explains why.
Worn and tired panels. A hood with peeling clear coat, a roof with fading, a bumper cover that has gone chalky, trim that has lost its color. Refinished or replaced to match the rest of the car. The auto painting page covers refinishing on its own.
Someone else's repair. A panel that does not match, a gap that is wrong, a bumper that was painted without being prepped and is now peeling, filler cracking under paint. Diagnosed honestly and redone properly.
Have a dent or a scrape that has bugged you for a year? Bring it in for a written price.
Repair the Panel or Replace It: How the Estimator Decides, and Why It Is Not Always the Cheaper One
A damaged panel is repaired when the metal can be returned to its original shape and strength and the result will be invisible; it is replaced when the damage is too sharp, too stretched, too rusted, or sits where the manufacturer says not to repair. The estimator decides by the damage and the manufacturer's rules, shows you both options when both exist, and tells you honestly which will look right in five years.
Repair versus replace is the central decision in body work, and it is not just about today's price.
When repair is right
A shallow dent in a flat area, a crease that has not stretched the metal, a scrape that took paint but not shape. The panel is worked back with dent tools and, where needed, a thin layer of filler to level the surface, then primed and painted. Steel repairs well; aluminum repairs less well and sometimes not at all because it does not move back the way steel does.
When replacement is right
A sharp crease that has stretched the metal so it will never lie flat, a dent across a body line or a sharp style crease, a panel with rust through it, a bolt-on panel where the labor to repair exceeds the cost of a new one, or any panel the manufacturer lists as replace-only. Doors, fenders, hoods, and trunk lids are bolt-on and replace cleanly; quarter panels and rockers are welded and replacing them is a bigger job, which is why a repairable quarter is usually repaired.
Original, aftermarket, or recycled
A replacement bolt-on panel can be new from the manufacturer, new from an aftermarket maker, or an original panel from a salvage car. For an out-of-pocket job you choose, and the estimate shows the difference. A recycled original door in the same color can be the best value on an older car. The parts section on the body shop page explains the three types.
What we will not do
Pile filler over a dent that should have been pulled, so it cracks next winter. Paint over rust. Repair a panel the manufacturer says to replace. Or quote the cheaper option without telling you why the other one exists. The estimate section on the body shop page describes how every job is written up.
Want both options priced? The estimate shows repair and replace side by side.
Rust at the Wheel Arches, Rockers, and Door Bottoms: Why It Is Cut Out and Replaced, Never Painted Over
Rust on a body panel is metal that is already gone, and the visible bubble is the small end of it. Macarthur cuts rusted metal back to clean steel, welds in new metal or a replacement section, seals the seams, and refinishes the area. Sanding rust smooth and painting over it looks fine for a season and bubbles again, because the rust underneath never stopped.
Long Island's salted winters and salt air make rust the most common body job on cars more than a few years old. Here is where it starts, why it is worse than it looks, and what a real repair involves.
Where it starts. The rear wheel arches, where the inner and outer panels meet and road spray collects. Rocker panels under the doors, which trap moisture inside. The bottoms of doors and tailgates, where drain holes clog. Around the trunk seal and the rear window. Anywhere a chip in the paint let water reach bare steel.
Why the bubble is the small end. Rust spreads under the paint from the inside of the panel outward. By the time it bubbles the surface, the metal behind it is thinned or perforated across a wider area. Poke a bubble with a screwdriver and it usually goes through.
What a proper repair is. The rusted area is cut out to clean, solid metal with margin. A new section is formed or a manufacturer or aftermarket repair panel is fitted, welded in, and the welds ground and sealed. The inside of the panel is treated and the drain holes opened so water does not collect again. Then primer, seam sealer, paint, and blend.
What a cosmetic patch is. Grind the surface, fill the hole, paint. It looks fine on delivery and bubbles within a year because the rust under the filler is still spreading. We do not do this, and we tell you if a previous shop did.
Honest limits. A rocker that has rotted through its structure, a floor that has gone, or a frame rail with rust holes is structural rust and a bigger conversation. The estimator tells you what he finds and whether the car is worth the repair. The small jobs section on the body shop page covers rust alongside the other work people pay for themselves.
Bubble at the wheel arch? Bring it in before it is a hole.
How an Auto Body Repair Goes at Macarthur: the Look, the Written Price, the Work, the Paint, and the Pickup
You bring the car in during shop hours, an estimator looks at it with you and writes an itemized price, you approve it, the car is scheduled, the panel is repaired or replaced, primed, painted, and blended, the car is reassembled and inspected, and you pick it up and walk around it in daylight. The written price is the price unless you approve a change.
An out-of-pocket repair is simpler than a claim because there is no adjuster in the middle. Here is what it looks like.
The look. No appointment needed. Monday through Friday 8 AM to 5 PM or Saturday 9 AM to 12 PM at 170 East Lincoln Avenue. The estimator walks around the car with you, looks at the damage in daylight, checks the panel edges for hidden damage or old filler, and asks what you want: invisible, or good enough for a car you are selling.
The written price. Itemized: labor by operation, parts by type if any, paint by panel including blend, materials. If repair and replace are both options, both are priced. If part of the job is cosmetic and can wait, it is marked. You take the paper home.
Scheduling. Small jobs are scheduled around the collision work and your calendar. Some can be done while you wait; most take a day or more because paint needs to cure. The timeline section on the body shop page explains what moves a date.
The work. Dents pulled, panels replaced, rust cut out, as described above. Trim and hardware removed so paint edges are not taped, and reinstalled afterward.
Paint and blend. Color matched to the code and the car, blended into the adjacent panel, cleared and polished. The paint section on the body shop page describes the process.
Pickup. The walk-around in daylight, the invoice matching the estimate, payment settled with the office. The pickup section covers what to bring.
Stop in during shop hours. The price is on paper before any work starts.
Paying Yourself or Filing a Claim: How to Decide, and Why the Estimate Is Written the Same Way Either Way
Most auto body repairs are paid out of pocket because the cost is close to the deductible or the owner would rather not involve the insurer. Macarthur writes the estimate the same way whether you or an insurer pays, so you can compare the number to your deductible and decide. If you file a claim, the shop handles it as it does any collision claim.
The shop does not tell you what to do with your policy. It gives you the number and the facts so you can decide.
When paying yourself usually makes sense. The repair is at or below your deductible. It is a single-car incident with no other party. You would rather keep a small incident off your record. The car is older and the job is cosmetic.
When a claim usually makes sense. The repair is well above the deductible. Another driver was at fault and their insurer is paying. Hidden damage might turn a small job into a large one. The incident is already on record.
The estimate is the same paper. Itemized parts, labor, paint, and materials, with safety and structural items separated from cosmetic ones. If you decide to file after seeing it, the shop sends the same estimate to the insurer and handles the claim; the insurance section on the body shop page describes that process.
Doing part now and part later. For an out-of-pocket job you can fix the door now and the bumper scuff next month, and the estimate is written so you can see each piece. What the shop will tell you honestly is which items are about safety or rust that spreads, and which are purely about looks.
Payment. Settled at pickup with the office. Ask when you book the work about how you would like to pay.
Want the number before you decide about a claim? That is what the estimate is for.
Steel, Aluminum, Plastic, and Composite Panels: Why the Material Changes How the Repair Is Done
Most body panels are steel, which bends and can be worked back. A growing number of hoods, doors, and fenders are aluminum, which does not move back the same way and often has to be replaced. Bumper covers are plastic and are repaired with plastic welding or adhesives. Some panels are composite or bonded and have their own rules. Macarthur identifies the material first and repairs it the way the manufacturer specifies.
The same dent in two different materials can be a quick repair or a replacement, and a shop that treats them the same does damage.
Steel. Worked back with hammers, dollies, dent pullers, and stud welders, then leveled with a thin skim of filler where needed. High-strength steel used in some structural areas has limits on heating and reshaping that the manufacturer publishes, and those are followed.
Aluminum. Lighter, more common every year on hoods, fenders, doors, and liftgates. It work-hardens and cracks when worked too much, cannot be heated the way steel can, and must be repaired with dedicated tools in a separate area so steel dust does not contaminate it and cause corrosion. Many aluminum dents are replacements for that reason, and the estimator says so.
Plastic bumper covers. Scuffs are sanded and refinished. Cracks and torn tabs are plastic-welded or bonded with the right adhesive for the plastic type, then refinished with a flex additive. Deformed covers are replaced. The bumper repair page goes deeper.
Composite and bonded panels. Fiberglass and SMC panels on some trucks and vans, bonded roof skins and quarter panels on some cars. These are repaired with the manufacturer's adhesive and procedure or replaced; they are not welded.
Why it matters for the price. An aluminum fender replacement costs more than a steel fender repair, and the estimate tells you which you have before you decide. The collision repair process section on the body shop page describes the same material rules in the context of a larger repair.
Aluminum hood with a dent? Ask before anyone pulls on it.
Body Work on Work Vans, Fleet Pickups, and Lettered Trucks: Keeping the Vehicle Earning While It Looks Right
Work vehicles get dented, scraped, and rusted faster than private cars and are harder to take off the road. Macarthur repairs van sides, pickup beds, rocker rust, and bumper damage on fleet units, coordinates lettering and wraps with your sign company for the repaired panel, and for fleet accounts schedules the work around the vehicle's route.
A van with a crushed side still works; a van that looks like that in a customer's driveway costs you the next job. Here is how the fleet body work goes.
Vans and cutaways. Long flat sides that catch every pole and mirror, sliding door tracks that get bent, rear doors that get backed into. Steel and aluminum sides are repaired or sectioned; fiberglass box panels are repaired with the box builder's procedure.
Pickups. Bed sides dented from loading, tailgates bent, rockers rusted from salt and gravel. Bed sides are welded panels and are usually repaired rather than replaced; tailgates are bolt-on and swap cleanly.
Lettering and wraps. A repaired and repainted panel loses its lettering. We coordinate with your sign company so the new panel is ready for the graphic, or arrange for the wrap section to be reapplied, and the truck goes back on the road looking like the rest of the fleet.
Scheduling. For a fleet account the work is booked around the route, the estimate is written the day the vehicle arrives, and you have one contact. The commercial section on the body shop page and the commercial accounts section on the towing page explain how accounts are arranged. If the unit cannot be driven, our own truck brings it in.
Fleet unit scraped up? Book the work around its route, not the other way around.
Auto Body Repair for Drivers Across Nassau County and the Queens Line, at One Shop in Valley Stream
The body shop is at 170 East Lincoln Avenue in Valley Stream. Drivers bring cars to it from every town in Nassau County, the Queens neighborhoods along the county line, and the Suffolk towns just across it, during shop hours or on a Macarthur tow truck if the car cannot be driven. Every town has its own auto body repair page.
A dent in Hempstead, a scraped door in Freeport, rust on a rocker in Lynbrook, Elmont, Franklin Square, West Hempstead, Rockville Centre, Oceanside, Baldwin, Long Beach, or the Five Towns around Cedarhurst, Lawrence, and Hewlett is a short drive to the shop, and so is one across the line in Laurelton, Rosedale, Springfield Gardens, Cambria Heights, St. Albans, Hollis, Jamaica, or Far Rockaway.
From central and eastern Nassau, Garden City, Mineola, Williston Park, Westbury, East Meadow, Levittown, Hicksville, Plainview, Merrick, Bellmore, Wantagh, and Massapequa, from the north shore towns of Great Neck, Manhasset, Roslyn, Glen Cove, and Syosset, and from Amityville, Melville, and Huntington on the Suffolk side, the shop is the same shop. The full list is on the locations page.
Find your town and its auto body repair page.
More Body Shop Services From the Same Shop
Collision Repair
From fender benders to major damage, repaired to pre-accident condition.
Auto Painting
Spot repair to full repaints, matched to the factory color.
Frame Repair
Frames pulled back to straight and true.
Auto Glass Replacement
Windshields, door glass, and back glass replaced.
Bumper Repair
Cracked, scraped, or pushed-in bumpers repaired or replaced.
Dent Repair
Door dings, hail, and creased panels.
One shop covers every repair on the list.
Questions Drivers Ask About Auto Body Repair
- Do you do small body jobs without an insurance claim?
- Yes. Dents, scrapes, rust, and panel work are quoted for a written price and paid out of pocket by most customers. The estimate is written the same way as a claim so you can compare it to your deductible.
- Can I get a price without an appointment?
- Yes. Bring the car to 170 East Lincoln Avenue, Valley Stream, Monday through Friday 8 AM to 5 PM or Saturday 9 AM to 12 PM, and an estimator looks at it with you and writes the price.
- Will you repair the panel or replace it?
- It depends on the damage and the material. Shallow dents and scrapes in steel are repaired; sharp creases, stretched metal, rust-through, aluminum panels that will not work back, and panels the manufacturer lists as replace-only are replaced. The estimate shows both options when both exist.
- Can rust be sanded and painted over?
- No. Rust spreads under the paint from inside the panel, and painting over it bubbles again within a year. Rusted metal is cut out to clean steel and new metal is welded in.
- Do you fix rust on rocker panels and wheel arches?
- Yes. Those are the most common rust jobs on Long Island. The rusted section is cut out, a new section is welded in, the inside is treated, and the area is refinished.
- Will the paint match the rest of the car?
- Yes. The painter mixes to the factory code, tests against the car's actual shade, and blends into the adjacent panel so there is no edge.
- Can you fix a repair another shop did badly?
- Yes. Mismatched panels, wrong gaps, peeling bumpers, cracking filler. We diagnose what was done and redo it properly.
- Is aluminum harder to repair than steel?
- Yes. Aluminum does not work back the way steel does and needs separate tools. Many aluminum dents are replacements, and the estimator tells you which you have.
- Can I do part of the work now and the rest later?
- Yes, for an out-of-pocket job. The estimate is itemized so you can see each piece, and the shop tells you which items are about safety or spreading rust and which are purely cosmetic.
- Do you use original, aftermarket, or recycled panels?
- For an out-of-pocket job, you choose, and the estimate shows each option. A recycled original panel in the same color can be the best value on an older car.
- How long does a small body job take?
- It depends on the job and the paint work. Some are done while you wait; most take a day or more because paint needs to cure. You get a realistic window when the work is booked.
- Do you do body work on work vans and fleet trucks?
- Yes. Van sides, pickup beds, rockers, and bumpers on fleet units, scheduled around the route, with lettering and wraps coordinated with your sign company.
- If my car cannot be driven, can you pick it up?
- Yes. Our own tow trucks bring it to the shop, 24 hours a day. Call 516-362-5350.
- Where is the shop?
- 170 East Lincoln Avenue, Valley Stream, NY 11580. Shop hours are Monday through Friday 8 AM to 5 PM and Saturday 9 AM to 12 PM.
Did not see your question? Ask the estimator.
Call Macarthur for a Written Price on Any Body Job
Dents, scrapes, rust, and panels at a certified shop in Valley Stream. Stop in during shop hours or have us tow it in.
Call 516-362-5350